Cost Engineering for Construction: How Owners Can Improve Budget and Schedule Certainty
Too often, the process of creating estimates and budgets for complex construction projects remains stuck in the past, focusing on narrowly defined information and limited research. As project complexity increases and economic and supply chain challenges multiply, an innovative practice called Cost Engineering is emerging as a powerful way to keep construction projects on track.
According to a McKinsey report, “Ninety-eight percent of megaprojects suffer cost overruns of more than 30 percent; 77 percent are at least 40 percent late.”
In How Big Things Get Done, authors Bent Flyvbjerg and Dan Gardner explore why large-scale construction and infrastructure projects often fail to deliver on time, on budget, and meet all Owner requirements. They conclude that many of these failures result from flawed forecasting and planning processes, such as the use of overly optimistic estimates and insufficient consideration of risks.
Cost Engineering represents a promising remedy to the problems Flyvbjerg and Gardner highlight.
The Limits of Traditional Cost Estimating
Traditional cost estimating still plays an important role in construction, but on complex projects it often relies on incomplete information and limited analysis.
In many cases, the process works like this:
- The Owner, General Contractor (GC), and Architect provide Cost Estimators with project data describing direct costs, such as financial information from the Owner, design data from the Architects and Engineers (A&E), and baseline norms for construction costs. Typically, indirect and soft costs are not addressed.
- Using heuristic accounting estimates (i.e., “rules of thumb” based on experience), the estimator creates a spreadsheet that represents a qualified guess of the ultimate cost of the major parts of the project and the project as a whole.
- Cost Estimators generally do not seek to significantly expand the amount of data provided by performing research about external factors such as labor costs, supply chain issues, or other factors that may influence the estimate.
- Cost Estimators generally do not collaborate extensively with the rest of the project team or external experts to gain more information and insight.
Because the process is not detailed and exhaustive, expectations are low for the accuracy of the resulting numbers. Cost Estimates are seen as a “best effort” attempt to get a ballpark cost for a project. Creating a first draft of a cost model for a project can be quite useful as a way to focus on controlling costs in specific areas.
But compared to Cost Engineering, the level of detail provided by ballpark cost models and the information they are based on are quite narrow. In the modern world of complex construction, ballpark Cost Estimates are becoming less relevant and useful. As Flyvbjerg and Gardner point out, without an accurate estimate of costs, projects have a much higher risk of getting out of control with respect to scope, budget, and timeline.
What Makes Cost Engineering Different?
Cost Engineering is a more comprehensive discipline designed to improve forecasting and decision-making on construction projects.
Unlike traditional cost estimating, Cost Engineering combines estimating expertise with economic analysis, market research, schedule risk assessment, value management, and ongoing evaluation as the project evolves. It is not just about producing a number. It is about understanding whether a budget is realistic, where the risks are, and what options exist to improve outcomes.
Unlike traditional cost estimating, Cost Engineering combines estimating expertise with economic analysis, market research, schedule risk assessment, value management, and ongoing evaluation as the project evolves. It is not just about producing a number. It is about understanding whether a budget is realistic, where the risks are, and what options exist to improve outcomes.
Cost Engineering is especially valuable when:
- project scope is large or complex
- market conditions are volatile
- schedules are aggressive
- design is still evolving
- Owners need to evaluate alternatives or manage change
By giving Owners a more complete picture of cost and risk, Cost Engineering supports better planning from the start and better control throughout the life of the project.
What is Cost Engineering?
Here is a review of the critical components and foundational knowledge that make up a strong and innovative Cost Engineering practice but are absent from the traditional practice of Cost Estimating:
Economic Analysis
Construction projects are inherently influenced by economic factors such as labor availability, material prices, and market trends. Skilled Cost Engineers must possess strong economic analysis capabilities to assess these factors and their potential impact on project costs. This may involve researching local labor markets, evaluating material price trends, and incorporating escalation factors into Cost Estimates.
Detailed Cost Estimating
Detailed and multi-layered spreadsheet models still matter in Cost Engineering as long as they are backed up by exhaustive research. As projects progress and design details become available, Cost Engineers utilize detailed Cost Estimating methods to produce precise cost breakdowns for labor, materials, equipment, and other project components. Generating accurate estimates involves a thorough analysis of construction drawings, specifications, and market conditions.
Parametric Cost Estimating
Parametric Cost Estimating uses historical project data and modeling to develop preliminary Cost Estimates at the early stages of a project when detailed design information is limited. Instead of a detailed spreadsheet with a line for every cost, the parametric approach starts with a variety of metrics about a building, such as material types, labor hours per unit, the project’s complexity, and more. These are then used as inputs to develop a model using historical project data from similar buildings. The parametric approach enables Cost Engineers to quickly assess the feasibility of different design concepts and provide valuable insights to Owners about potential costs.
Construction Schedule Risk Analysis (CSRA)
Delays and schedule changes are common causes of cost overruns. Cost Engineers utilize CSRA techniques to identify potential schedule risks, assess their likelihood and impact, and develop mitigation strategies. This involves analyzing the project schedule, identifying critical activities, and evaluating potential delays due to factors such as weather, material availability, and contractor performance. Incorporating CSRA into Cost Engineering enables Owners to make informed decisions about schedule trade-offs and contingency planning.
Value Management
Cost engineers play an active role in value management. This collaborative process optimizes project value by identifying design alternatives that enhance functionality and/or reduce costs without compromising quality or performance. Cost engineers work closely with the design team to evaluate different materials, systems, and construction methods to find the most cost-effective solutions.
Change Order Analysis
Unexpected design changes and unforeseen site conditions often necessitate change orders during construction. Cost Engineers are essential in analyzing these changes, assessing their impact on the budget and schedule, and negotiating fair pricing with contractors. They meticulously evaluate the contractor’s proposed costs, ensuring they are justified and aligned with market rates.
Technical Writing and Communication
Effective communication is crucial for Cost Engineers. They must clearly articulate their findings, assumptions, and recommendations to Owners, Design Teams, and Contractors. This requires strong technical writing skills to produce concise and accurate Cost Estimates, reports, and RFIs (Requests for Information).
Software Proficiency
While core Cost Engineering principles remain constant, technological advancements continuously reshape the industry. Proficiency in specialized Cost Estimating software, such as MCACES 2nd Generation (MII) and Oracle Crystal Ball, is increasingly important for managing large datasets, generating detailed cost breakdowns, and streamlining the estimating process. It’s important to recognize software is simply a tool that complements, rather than replaces, the expertise and judgment of a skilled Cost Engineer.
Negotiation and Problem Solving
Cost Engineers often find themselves at the center of negotiations among Owners, Designers, and Contractors, working to find solutions that balance budget constraints, design goals, and constructability concerns. Strong negotiation and problem-solving skills are essential for Cost Engineers to effectively navigate these complex situations and achieve mutually acceptable outcomes.
The essential skills detailed above, coupled with specialized software tools, equip Cost Engineers to navigate the complexities of modern construction.
The Impact of Cost Engineering for Owners
Cost Engineering equips Owners with the insights and guidance needed to control costs, mitigate risks, and ultimately, realize their project vision within budget. By using Cost Engineering, Owners can make informed decisions about project trade-offs, contingency planning, and value management. The practice of Cost Engineering ensures that project budgets are realistic, not overly optimistic. With detailed analysis and a collaborative approach, Cost Engineering enables Owners to realize their project vision within budget and on schedule.
A Better Way to Control Cost, Risk, and Project Delivery
As construction projects grow more complex, traditional estimating alone is no longer enough. Owners need a deeper, more dynamic understanding of cost, schedule risk, and market conditions.
Cost Engineering provides that capability. By combining detailed estimating with economic analysis, collaboration, schedule risk evaluation, and ongoing cost management, it helps Owners improve certainty and make better decisions throughout the project lifecycle.
The result is a more realistic path to delivering projects on budget and on schedule.
How MOCA Services Supports Cost Engineering
The Cost Engineering team at MOCA Systems, Inc. has the experience, tools, and industry knowledge to help Owners strengthen cost planning on complex construction projects. Whether you need an independent second opinion or want to improve your overall approach to project budgeting and forecasting, MOCA Services can help you use Cost Engineering to reduce risk, improve cost certainty, and support successful delivery.